In this part we see more contradicting Shia narrations on Imamah, `Ali asking for martyrdom in battle while knowing that he is supposed to succeed the Prophet (saw), Also a lot of narrations on the Prophet (saw) waiting to receive revelation to know who his successor is although he should have known it already.
Books
Imamah wal-Nass – 4
In this part we begin to show how all those lovely sounding narrations will fall apart after a little common sense is applied. We start from where it all began with the birth of `Ali.
Books
Imamah wal-Nass – 8
In this part, we continue showing the ignorance of the companions of Rasul-Allah (saw) about Imamah and how they kept asking over and over again about the identity of the successors.
Articles
The Vague Appointment of `Ali
Imami Shia claim and base their entire religion on the appointment of `Ali bin abi Talib through a divine text as leader of mankind after Rasul-Allah (saw). When asked for evidence they will throw any virtue they find for `Ali [read more]
Leave a Reply